The Economist
To accompany The Economist’s special report on the news industry, Jay Rosen and Nicholas Carr are debating whether the Internet is making journalism better. Rosen acknowledges the economic harm of lower employment and a greater supply of journalistic “rubbish.” But he argues that’s outweighed by all the benefits, such as a lower cost of doing journalism, new newsgathering and publication tools, and a shift in power from institutions to users. “Journalism is not like brain surgery or flying a 747, which are not improved by having more hands on deck,” he writes. “The field is better for gaining a more participatory public at its receiving end.” Carr, author of “The Shallows,” argues that the Internet has thinned the ranks of professional journalists without offering anything to fill the gap. He notes that the Internet has enabled innovations such as crowdsourcing and citizen journalism, but says, “It is important to recognise that they supplement rigorous, tenacious, in-depth reporting; they do not replace it.” The debate will continue with rebuttals on Friday and closing arguments in a week. Anyone can vote; as of Tuesday morning, 72 percent agreed that the Internet is making journalism better.
Uncategorized
Economist debate: Is the Internet making journalism better or worse?
Tags: MediaWire, Top Stories
More News
Topography of a news ecosystem: A first-of-its-kind study diagnoses the local news crisis in a single state
Media scholars at the University of Maryland documented the spread of local news dead spots — and unexpected vibrant areas — in that state.
April 19, 2024
$12 million Global Fact Check Fund opens applications for second year of grants
A partnership between Poynter’s International Fact-Checking Network and Google and YouTube continues to support fact-checking initiatives worldwide
April 19, 2024
Opinion | A columnist made a controversial introduction to Caitlin Clark
IndyStar sports columnist Gregg Doyel has been crushed online and accused of being creepy, sexist and worse. He’s since apologized multiple times
April 19, 2024
‘Satanic rituals’ at Taylor Swift shows? That’s false. And experts say the attack isn’t new.
Experts say musicians have been accused of performing satanic rituals for decades
April 19, 2024
How a longtime film critic’s death represents the great dissolve of local film criticism
Bryan VanCampen of The Ithaca Times was an institution in the central New York college town of 32,000. He might have been the last of his kind.
April 18, 2024