News & Tips
Training
Chats
Top Story
Public TV, Radio Stations to Increase Local Investigative Coverage
Most Recent Articles
1.
Poynter's Times Publishing Co. sells Governing
5:15 PM Nov. 20, 2009
2.
Recommendation for Fewer PAP Screens Sure to Set Off Controversy
10:32 AM Nov. 20, 2009
3.
Gene Patterson to Jack Nelson: Save Us a Desk Up There in That Celestial Newsroom
7:03 AM Nov. 20, 2009
4.
Public TV, Radio Stations to Increase Local Investigative Coverage
6:19 AM Nov. 20, 2009
5.
Woods: Plagiarism Never Justified
3:47 PM Nov. 19, 2009
More Recent Articles
6.
What Great Bosses Know about Quiet Leaders
3:39 PM Nov. 19, 2009
7.
Archived Chat: How can Journalism Schools Encourage Innovation?
2:10 PM Nov. 19, 2009
8.
Studying Newspapers in a Time of Change
11:51 AM Nov. 19, 2009
9.
Testing CUNY's New Business Models with Adjusted Assumptions
10:29 AM Nov. 19, 2009
10.
How Do I Protect My Publication Rights?
4:48 AM Nov. 19, 2009
Fewer Recent Articles
Most E-mailed
1.
Good Decisions and Great Journalism
12:00 AM Aug. 4, 2002
More E-mailed Articles
Recent Comments
1.
Group therapy-type journalism
on
CNN's John King believes in steering conversations
Posted By:
Tom Traubert
11:29 PM Nov. 20, 2009
2.
Free E-Meters to St. Pete Times subscribers?
on
Poynter's Times Publishing Co. sells Governing
Posted By:
Bradley Fikes
8:25 PM Nov. 20, 2009
3.
Daley's talk
on
Chicago mayor blames media for Oprah's departure
Posted By:
Robb Hill
4:26 PM Nov. 20, 2009
4.
Huh?
on
Chicago mayor blames media for Oprah's departure
Posted By:
Jeffrey Knight
1:40 PM Nov. 20, 2009
5.
T'was the blog post, not the call
on
More on the Post-Dispatch vulgar comment brouhaha
Posted By:
Allan Maurer
1:19 PM Nov. 20, 2009
More Recent Comments
6.
Not just King ...
on
CNN's John King believes in steering conversations
Posted By:
Alex Dering
12:33 PM Nov. 20, 2009
7.
What is King? A group therapist
on
CNN's John King believes in steering conversations
Posted By:
Tom Traubert
12:13 PM Nov. 20, 2009
8.
Tom Traubert is a fake name
on
Fayetteville editor protests Palin coverage blackout
Posted By:
Bradley Fikes
11:08 AM Nov. 20, 2009
9.
What about the issue touched on in the cartoon?
on
Newsday under fire for running "Fillmore" cartoon
Posted By:
Algerco Algerco
10:58 AM Nov. 20, 2009
10.
Great initiative
on
Testing CUNY's New Business Models with Adjusted Assumptions
Posted By:
Reginald Addae
10:51 AM Nov. 20, 2009
Fewer Recent Comments
Recent Tags
1.
Careers: Transitions
2.
Magazines
3.
Media criticism
4.
Business models
5.
Advertising
More Recent Tags
6.
Layoffs/buyouts/staff cuts
7.
Investigative journalism
8.
Careers: Development /growth
9.
Live Chat
10.
Newsroom culture
Fewer Recent Tags
Community Activity
Welcome
michael drury
to the
Journalism Conversations: TV & Radio
group.
Read
Julian Cordero's
blog post
A simple way we can all share the wealth!
in the
Ethics & Diversity
blog.
Read
Gena Fitzgerald's
comment to the blog post
new media titles?
in the
Online & Multimedia
blog.
View a
photo
that
Bob Howarth
has posted.
Poynter Seminars
Small, in-person training experiences.
1.
A New Curriculum for a New Journalism - Jan. 6-8, 2010
Apply by November 23
2.
Multimedia Journalism for College Educators - February 1-5, 2010
Apply by December 14
3.
NewsU: Write Your Heart Out: The Craft of the Personal Essay - January 25-February 19, 2010
Apply by January 4
All Poynter Seminars
News University
Today's most popular courses on NewsU, Poynter's e-learning site for journalists.
All NewsU Courses
Webinars
Our online classroom is just a click away. Learn more.
All Webinars
Romenesko
Latest News
Reporting
& Writing
Ethics &
Diversity
Leadership
& Business
Visual
Journalism
Online &
Technology
TV &
Radio
Journalism
Education
Chip on Your Shoulder
Home
>
Reporting, Writing & Editing
>
Chip on Your Shoulder
Tools:
Text Size
or
,
Print
,
RSS
,
Subscribe via e-mail
Chip Scanlan
Sharing the writing life with Chip Scanlan.
ABOUT
Why I Blog
The Story Behind the Name
SERIES
ABCs OF ONLINE WRITING
H is for Hypertext: What Makes a Good Link
T is for Tool: What's Inside Today's Journalism Toolbox
ASK CHIP
How Do You Trap Words Spell-Check Misses?
An Online Opportunity to Learn the Writing Process
Says vs. Said
Should My Writing Turn the Other Cheek?
What to Do When Schools Change Names
Deconstructing the Dash
ASK CHIP: A new service for writers and editors
CHIP'S NEWSU COURSES
Get Me Rewrite: The Craft of Revision
The Lead Lab
The Interview
Writers @ Work: A Process Approach
BOOKS
"Reporting and Writing: Basics for the 21st Century"
Oxford University Press
"The Holly Wreath Man"
Andrews McMeel Publishing
ESSAYS
"My Cancer Time Bomb"
Salon.com
"Leave Me Alone, AARP"
Salon.com
"The Hardest Habit to Kick: A Confession"
National Public Radio
"The Only Honest Man"
River Teeth: A Journal of Nonfiction Narrative
"Reading the Paper"
The American Scholar
REPORTING
"Made in the Shade"
Creative Loafing
"Mass Appeal"
Catholic Digest
"The Liberation of Tam Minh Pham"
The Washington Post Magazine
FICTION
Holly Wreaths Across America
Online map of the newspapers in which "The Holly Wreath Man" has been published.
Mystery @ Elf Camp
with Katharine Fair
"The Needle"
A Novel in Progress
"Mad Looper"
MississippiReview.com
Getting it Right: A Passion for Accuracy
Have you ever been on the receiving end of journalism: the subject of, or even just a mention in, a news story ? Perhaps it was about a friend or relative. Did they get it right? Ask reporters and editors this question and you'll get a catalogue of misspelled names, misquotes, factual errors.
Surveys
show that the public expects the news media to be accurate, even though people are less confident than they used to be that news organizations get the facts right. Accuracy is a mind-set, an attitude. The best reporters I know die a thousand deaths when they learn a story they wrote includes an error. Everyone makes mistakes, no one is perfect, but journalists must take great care to get it right. Otherwise they lose a news organization's greatest asset: credibility.
Accuracy is the goal; fact-checking is the process.
After tracking errors in
The Oregonian
of Portland, editors concluded that the three most frequent sources of error are:
Working from memory.
Making assumptions.
Dealing with second-hand sources.
The way to achieve accuracy is to develop a system and adhere to it religiously. In "
Newspaper Credibility Handbook
," an American Society of Newspaper Editors study,
The Oregonian
's Michele McClellan spotlights several excellent approaches, linked in the accompanying sidebar. One of my favorite resources for improving accuracy is "
44 Tips for Greater Accuracy
," by Frank E. Fee. Jr., the Knight Professor of Editing at Ohio University. Aimed at copy editors, Fee's tips contain invaluable advice for reporters as well.
If you're having an accuracy problem, pay attention to three faultlines as you go about your job:
More resources
Details Matter
by
Michele
McLellan
Accuracy Checklist
San Jose Mercury News
Verification Guidelines
Kansas City Star
44 Tips for Greater Accuracy
by Frank E. Fee, Jr.
DURING THE REPORTING
, take the extra seconds to read back the spelling of the source's name. Ask for the person's age. If you ask for birthdate and year, you'll always have the information needed to update an age.
DURING THE WRITING
, consult your documentary sources -- notebook, printed materials -- as you're writing. If you don't want to interrupt the writing flow, make sure to put a mark reminding you to double-check it later. "CK" for "check" is the standard proofreader's mark. "CQ" is shorthand for "this has been checked for accuracy"; it is often used with unusual spellings, facts and figures.
AFTER THE WRITING
, assemble all your source materials -- notebooks, interview transcripts, tapes, books, studies, photographs -- everything you've used to report and write your story. Then go over every single word in the story and compare it to the original source. It's time consuming, but you can sleep a little easier. On projects and even on daily stories, I made one printout just for names and titles, another for quotes, a third for other factual details.
Call your source back and double-check. If you're describing a financial transaction, a medical procedure or how a sewer bond works, there's nothing wrong with calling the source and asking him or her to listen to what you've written. Your obligation is to be clear and accurate.
Listen to the voice in your head. Whenever I made a mistake in a story, I could always go back to a moment where it happened. Usually it was an assumption I made or a question I failed to address. There is a moment of truth in writing where you can take either the accurate path or the inaccurate path.
I was obsessive about it, but in 22 years as a reporter, I wrote stories that had corrections appended only about a half-dozen times. That doesn't mean all my other stories were error-free.
Errors are the bane of journalists. As a new reporter, I used to keep my corrections in my top desk drawer; I wanted their presence to haunt me. Reporters who start their careers working for small-town papers learn an unforgettable lesson about accuracy when they make a mistake in an obituary and hear from the deceased's survivors. One of the disadvantages of the electronic newsroom is that reporters may not come into contact with the people they hurt with incorrect information.
Some
magazines
employ fact-checkers. They verify names, titles, ages, addresses and the gist of quotations in the story.
"Fact-checking is the stage in the editorial process where someone attempts independent confirmation of every fact in an author's manuscript before its publication," according to Richard Blow and Ari Posner, who described their adventures in fact-checking in
The New Republic
. It's a luxury that newspaper reporters rarely enjoy.
Most professional reporters know they must act as their own fact-checkers. If you get small things wrong, you won't be trusted with big things. What news organizations have to sell, especially now with technology giving anyone the opportunity to report news electronically, is credibility.
I don't think a story without some mistakes exists, including this one. Appalachian quiltmakers put mistakes in their work because, they say, the devil loves perfection, but the careful, responsible reporter tries hard to get it right.
How do make sure you get it right in your stories? Share your best tips for improving accuracy.
Posted by
Chip Scanlan
at 8:15 AM on Aug. 24, 2004
Tools:
Comment
,
e-mail
,
Permalink
,
Share
Recent Comments:
Learned it the hard way
My first story at my new job (my first job),...
More.
Read All Comments (3 comments)
Latest Poynter Blogs (
See All Blogs
)
Romenesko
Poynter's Times Publishing Co. sells Governing
Al's Morning Meeting
Recommendation for Fewer PAP Screens Sure to Set Off Controversy
E-Media Tidbits
Testing CUNY's New Business Models with Adjusted Assumptions
Ask the Recruiter
How Do I Protect My Publication Rights?
The Biz Blog
Murdoch and Microsoft's Bing: A Media Marriage Made in Heaven?
NewsPay
Study: Newspapers Need to 'Shed Legacy Costs' to Capture Online Ad Spending
Transformation Tracker
Tracking the Future of Advertising
SuperVision
What Great Bosses Know about Quiet Leaders
Diversity at Work
When is Fort Hood Suspect's Faith Relevant in Media Coverage?
Shop
About Poynter
Give to Poynter
The Kennedys: America's Front Page Family
50 years in newspapers
$16.99
Buy Event Tickets
Write Your Way Into College, $149
Saturday, Dec. 9, 2009
Writing With Roy, $149
Saturday, Dec. 12, 2009
Who We Are
& What We Do
History and mission
Where is Poynter?
The Institute's location
Faculty & Staff Listings
Contact information
Poynter on the Record
Faculty in the news
Resource Center
Tips & Bibliographies
Invest in Journalism
Your gifts support Poynter's teaching and provide scholarships.
Advertise
You aim, we deliver
Reach thousands of journalists with your message on Poynter Online.
RSS
|
Podcasts
|
Mobile
|
Twitter
|
Facebook
|
Contact
|
FAQ
Guidelines
|
Corrections
|
Privacy
|
Site Map
|
Press
|
Advertise
© 1995-2009 The Poynter Institute
801 Third Street South | St. Petersburg, FL 33701
Phone (888) 769-6837 | Fax (727) 553-4680
Username
Password
Remember Me
New User? Signup Now
See All Jobs
Add Your Resume
Post Your Job
Become a Member
More media jobs