Poynter Online Poynter Online
New UserLogin

PointsSouth - Logo
PointsSouth - Editions
PointsSouth - First Edition
PointsSouth - Second Edition
PointsSouth - Third Edition
PointsSouth - Fourth Edition
PointsSouth - Fourth Edition
PointsSouth - Beats
PointsSouth - Southeast
PointsSouth - East of 34th
PointsSouth - West of 34th
PointsSouth - Gulfport
PointsSouth - Northeast
PointsSouth - Maggiore
PointsSouth - The Point
PointsSouth - The Beach
PointsSouth - Media
PointsSouth - Text
PointsSouth - Photos
PointsSouth - Audio
PointsSouth - Video
PointsSouth - Graphics
PointsSouth
The Program
About the fellowship
PointsSouth
Meet the Team

Southeast
Ashley Mills
Joey Kirk
Shoshana Walter
Eric Chima

East of 34th
Mary Andom
Billy Kulpa
Julia Robinson
Mallary Jean Tenore

West of 34th
LeeAnn Watson
Bill Couch
Chasity Gunn
Liz Barry

Gulfport
Amanda Determan
Tory Hargro
Zack Quaintance
Matthew Pleasant

Northeast
I-Ching Ng
Cynthia Reynaud
Lauren Kuntz
Nick Escobar

Maggiore
Erik Oeverndiek
Erin Cubert
Isabel Ordonez
Kalen Ponche

The Point
Tracy Boyer
Shirley Knowles
Jeremy G. Burton
Marissa Harshman

The Beach
Jenessa Farnsworth
Jason Fritz
Arek Sarkissian
Dwayne Steward
PointsSouth
The Faculty
Program instructors
PointsSouth
Previous Years
See past projects





PointsSouth: Articles 2007
The online publication of Poynter's Summer Program for Recent College Graduates.

Add/View All PointsSouth: Articles 2007 Feedback
More PointsSouth: Articles 2007

Personal Narrative - Joey Kirk
Pacing. Only two hours to go. Deadline is at noon.

I got an early jump on it only to change it three more times. But every copy I produce- worthless.

I started writing about my father. Then I wrote about dropping my phone in a giant puddle during a tropical storm.

Trying to write a masterpiece, but I am left with a pile of meaningless words. The connection I cannot make. What do these events have to do with me, my work or my career? They don't.

I keep trying to make significance out of moments that just aren't that significant. All of these moments, worthless.

Everybody else can pinpoint one time or a series of events that led to a revelation. Me ... I got nothing. I'm worthless.

I get up from the computer. I have to clear my head. I walk down the hallways of The Poynter Institute, to the giant ball of type: Charles Parkhill's the Messenger. I had passed it a few times, and on occasion, I had stopped to read some of the words trapped inside of it, hidden to the eye.

Editorial. Lead. Beat. Who, what, when, where, why and how.

But at that moment, I notice a word I had never seen before.

Confident.

I stood there.

I pondered.

Why hadn't I noticed it before?

Had my eyes been drawn to it for a reason?

Thoughts began racing in my head.

This could be my moment.

Thinking, reflecting, looking back at my work in journalism, I have found that I am my own worst critic. As cliché as it may sound, it's true.

I never like the work I produce.

As a reporter, I used to rip my stories apart, word for word. I couldn't develop a structure; my flow wasn't fluid.

Had I continued as a reporter, I was destined to be a homeless failure. I found myself designing pages and enjoying slight success.

However, my illustrations are never good enough. My designs are never stellar.

Awards come and go, and for a brief moment, I am happy. But I always think, "I could've done more and it could have been that much better."

Nothing is ever good enough. I nitpick until I cannot take it anymore. I have colleagues, friends, parents who try to reassure me. They say my designs look great. They lie. I don't believe them.

The doubt started with a simple comment from a friend of mine: The day you begin to think you are good is the day you begin to suck.

I remember that every day while sitting in the newsroom.

Before coming to Poynter, I wondered why me, why was I selected? Before that, I wondered how I had gotten a job at The Arizona Republic. And even before that, I wondered how I got involved in "The Intern" competition last year that had landed me in both of those spots.

I'm not that good. I'm a fraud. A pretender.


The day I begin to boast, the day I begin to brag, the day I begin to get a big head, is the day I will lose my job to somebody half my age with twice my ability.

I return to the giant ball of words to get a second look. It is then, that I realize the word "confident" is actually a portion a bigger word, confidential.

Worthless, once again.

But I know what I saw within that ball of type. It spoke to me. Really.

Confidence was something I had been lacking during my time at Poynter. For five weeks, I witnessed the creative work of the other designers. My work couldn't compare.

Hudson Hornet was the crotchety old racecar in the Disney film "Cars." One of the great philosophers of modern times, he said it best when he described all the awards and trophies a car could win. "They're nothing but empty cups." After striving to win the immediate prize, I had failed to see the ultimate satisfaction of being happy with what I have accomplished.

I go back to the giant ball of type one more time. A new word floats to the surface:

Worthy. That's right, worthy. I'm worthy.

I look again, Oh, wait, that was "newsworthy."

Nevermind. The moment's gone.


Posted at 12:34:25 AM

E-mail this item | Add Your Comments | QuickLink this item: A126674


PointsSouth: Articles 2007 Archive
View items published between:   and   
(MM/DD/YYYY) (MM/DD/YYYY)

MAIN | Back to Top



Search Poynter Online
Search Poynter Online

Getting Beyond My Buyout and Back to Work
Getting Beyond My Buyout and Back to Work
New On Poynter
A Buyout Checklist
By Joe Grimm

Art and Immigration
By Mizanur Rahman

Gallery Life
By Sara Quinn

Movies for Managers
By Jill Geisler

Time to Stand Up
By Karen Brown Dunlap

Rampant Medicare Fraud
Al's Friday Meeting

Beijing Olympics
Page One Today

NY: No Non-Compete
Al's Thursday Meeting

Jobless at 6-Year High
Al's Thursday Meeting

Hyper-Local in Big D
By Rick Edmonds

Commenting All-Stars
By Ellyn Angelotti


  Site Map | Advertise | Search | Contact | FAQ | Our Guidelines QuickLink  
  Copyright © 1995-2008 The Poynter Institute
  801 Third Street South | St. Petersburg, FL 33701 | Phone (888) 769-6837
  Site developed & hosted by DataGlyphics, Inc.



Poynter Career Center
Friday: Are These Applications for Real?
Friendships for Work, Support