Poynter Online Poynter Online
New UserLogin
Poynter Online Main Page
Poynter Career Center
Design / Graphics
Diversity
Ethics
Leadership
Online
Photojournalism
Writing / Editing
TV / Radio
Journalism & Business Values
About Poynter
Seminars
Faculty
Columns
Resource Center
The Poynter Store

Help Poynter


Create Your Personal Page
Add Your Bio
Add Your Photo
Share Your Favorite Links

Signup for Poynter Newsletters
Get Poynter Delivered to Your PDA

ASNE Online Ethics Tool



Posted, Apr. 3, 2008
Updated, Apr. 6, 2008


QuickLink: A140846

New Frames Needed for Religion Reporting

By Bill Kirtz (more by author)
Professor, Northeastern University

E-mail this item
Print this Page
Add/View Comments on this Article (2)

To better serve an ever more-interested audience, reporters covering religious topics should avoid journalism’s traditional "conflict" model and beware of generalizations.

Speakers offered that advice this week at Northeastern University’s School of Journalism, adding that readers appreciate nuanced coverage of faith and spiritual issues.

Boston Globe religion reporter Michael Paulson, part of the Pulitzer Prize-winning team that uncovered sexual abuse by Catholic clergy, has found people "open to having an emotional experience" from long-form newspaper stories. One example: his 18,000-word series on a neighborhood church that showed what he called "the drama of ordinary life."

He said the nationwide media focus on church scandals, along with 9/11 and its aftermath, has made religious coverage "more focused" and encouraged reporters to treat spiritual institutions with the skepticism they give other powerful subjects.

Benjamin Hubbard, chair emeritus of comparative religion at California State University, Fullerton, and a blogger for The Orange County Register, noted that religion, values and spirituality permeate a range of important topics, including abortion rights, AIDS in Africa and the Iraq war.

So "it’s more and more important for reporters to be religiously literate," he said. Hubbard sees religious coverage improving but said the media tend to adapt  “conflict” models and present some clerics’ unguarded comments out of context.

Debra Mason, executive director of the Religion Newswriters Association and director of the Center on Religion & the Professions at the University of Missouri, Columbia, also criticized "conflict framing" and said many reporters fail to capture the complexity of faith.

She said reporters covering religion should remember, "You’re never an expert," be aware of their own biases and have a respectful attitude. "You can ask tough questions," she said, but argued that journalists should not try "to prove or disprove a faith."

She and other speakers noted blogs' increasingly important role as newspapers shrink staffs and news holes. As an example, she praised "Whispers in the Loggia," run by a 20-something Rocco Palma, who uses confidential, multiple sources to break important stories out of the secretive Vatican. Another blog she mentioned, Andrea Useem's ReligionWriter.com, presents "Fresh Ideas on Religion in Whole-Grain Journalism Form."

Mason said the press has failed most in the areas of evangelicals and Islam.  And Munir Shaikh, executive director of the Institute on Religion and Civic Values, formerly called the Council on Islamic Education stressed the need not to generalize.

He sees references to the "Muslim or Islamic "world," but notes that there’s no separate "world" and that this tends to homogenize a diverse peoples and views. Instead, he said. journalists should be specific, identifying for example a country in which there is a majority of Muslims.

Shaikh identified other easily misused terms. He said "jihad," often translated as "holy war," actually means "striving for the sake of God" and that "Radical" or "Islamist" labels are as much of a generalization as "Moderate."

But he ended by praising the media’s shift from portraying American Muslims as "exotic" to showing them as part of a culturally diverse nation.

E-mail this item
Print this Page
Add/View Comments on this Article (2)

Back to Top

  • Covering Religion Forums at Northeastern School of Journalism
  • What wasn't said

  • --VIEW ALL--





    Search Poynter Online
    Search Poynter Online

    My Boss Likes Me, He Likes Me Not
    My Boss Likes Me, He Likes Me Not
    New On Poynter
    Whither Bush's Blog?
    By Alan Abbey

    Olympian Ruling
    Al's Friday Meeting

    Tech-Savvy Cities
    Al's Friday Meeting

    Taking a Grammar Vote
    By Roy Peter Clark

    Covering Disabilities
    By Susan LoTempio

    News from Israel
    Page One Today

    Video Comments
    By Paul Bradshaw

    Papers Not Relevant?
    By Ernst Poulsen

    Digital Diversity
    By Sally Lehrman

    Related Content
    Related Faculty
    Related Seminars
    NewsU: Writers at Work: A Process Approach (W401W-08)
    Jun. 23, 2008 - Jul. 18, 2008
    App. deadline: May. 28, 2008

    Narrative Writing on Deadline With Tom French (W401C-08)
    Jul. 13-18, 2008
    App. deadline: May. 28, 2008

    NewsU: Writing Better Print Headlines
    Sep. 8, 2008 - Oct. 3, 2008
    App. deadline: Aug. 11, 2008

    National Writers Workshop: Ft. Lauderdale, Fla.
    Sep. 20-21, 2008
    App. deadline: Sep. 19, 2008

    Reporting & Writing for the Ethnic Media (W412-08)
    Oct. 20-24, 2008
    App. deadline: Sep. 8, 2008

      Site Map | Advertise | Search | Contact | FAQ | Our Guidelines QuickLink  
      Copyright © 1995-2008 The Poynter Institute
      801 Third Street South | St. Petersburg, FL 33701 | Phone (888) 769-6837
      Site developed & hosted by DataGlyphics, Inc.



    Poynter Career Center
    Friday: Can New Media Save My Career?
    Giving Credit Costs Little