Poynter Online Poynter Online
New UserLogin
Poynter Online Main Page
Poynter Career Center
Design / Graphics
Diversity
Ethics
Leadership
Online
Photojournalism
Writing / Editing
TV / Radio
Journalism & Business Values
About Poynter
Seminars
Faculty
Columns
Resource Center
The Poynter Store

Help Poynter


Create Your Personal Page
Add Your Bio
Add Your Photo
Share Your Favorite Links

Signup for Poynter Newsletters
Get Poynter Delivered to Your PDA

ASNE Online Ethics Tool



E-Media Tidbits
A group weblog by the sharpest minds in online media/journalism/publishing

Add/View All E-Media Tidbits Feedback
More E-Media Tidbits

Friday, June 2, 2006


Posted by Amy Gahran 9:07:54 AM
Has News Competition Outlived Its Usefulness?

Yesterday in E-Media Tidbits, Steffen Fjaervik wrote about the view that competition is endemic to the profession and business of journalism.

I'm going to push back on that. In my view, the strongly competitive culture of the news business is an adaptation that helped journalism mature and thrive over the last century. But times change.

It seems to me that media (all media, not just online) are evolving to become more integrated, collaborative, interactive, customized, and conversational. Given that -- plus overwhelming business pressures -- maybe our competitive culture is becoming an albatross around the neck of journalism.

Here's what I mean: Huge chunks of the traditional business model of news organizations are crumbling. Advertisers and consumers are shifting -- they can now reach each other directly and constructively, without our help, and they're busy creating their own media, too. Consolidation in the industry continues, drastically altering our competitive landscape.

And let's not forget: No one -- NO ONE -- can scoop the Internet. Ever.

Seems to me that under such circumstances, news organizations might do better to hone their unique strengths and collaborate more with other news organizations that offer complementary strengths -- similar to how weblogs support and enhance each other through cross-blog conversation. Imagine: someday a Pulitzer Prize might be awarded jointly to an enterprise reporting team spread across several news organizations. 

Maybe it's time to recognize and start dismantling the silos where we've unwittingly cornered ourselves in the name of "competition." Collaboration might be a way to create a more robust and distributed base of operations for traditional journalism. Fortunately, online media is an easy an inexpensive place to experiment, so it might be a good way to start.

Ultimately, what's more important -- the survival of quality journalism or the survival of the business structures that have supported professional journalists so far?

What are your thoughts on this? Please comment below.


E-mail this item | Add/View Feedback (8) | QuickLink this item: A102251



E-Media Tidbits Archive
View items published between:   and   
(MM/DD/YYYY) (MM/DD/YYYY)

MAIN | Back to Top




Search Poynter Online
Search Poynter Online

Stakes, Expectations Rise as Copy Desks Shrink
Stakes, Expectations Rise as Copy Desks Shrink
New On Poynter
Gas Station TV is Here
By Rick Edmonds

Doom, or Not?
By Alan Abbey

Hostages Freed
Page One Today

Secondhand Twitter
By Amy Gahran

How I Wrote Father Tim
By Roy Peter Clark

Stupid Filter Tricks
By Amy Gahran

Workers' Comp Stories
Al's Tuesday Meeting

Ideas from Art Caplan
Al's Monday Meeting

Price of AWOL Dads
By Bobbi Bowman

Today's Mini-Tidbits
By Amy Gahran

Poynter Summer Fellows
By Jan Leach

Russert & Catholicism
By Roy Peter Clark

Wikipedia Caves
By Fons Tuinstra

Tableau Vivant Q&A
By Sara Quinn


Resources
Get Tidbits by E-mail (and other Poynter columns)

View All Tidbits Feedback

Pre-11/2002 Archive

Tidbits editor:
Amy Gahran (USA)

Tidbits
Contributors:

Alan Abbey (Israel)
Paul Bradshaw (UK)
Matthew Buckland (S. Africa)
Juan C. Camus (Chile)
Thomas Crampton (Hong Kong)
Michelle Ferrier (USA)
A. Adam Glenn (USA)
Rich Gordon (USA)
Tish Grier (USA)
Barb Iverson (USA)
Steve Klein (USA)
Vincent Maher (S. Africa)
Maryn McKenna (USA)
Joe Michaud (USA)
Bill Mitchell (USA)
Steve Outing (USA)
Kim Pearson (USA)
Ernst Poulsen (Denmark)
Katja Riefler (Germany)
Laura Ruel (USA)
Ken Sands (USA)
Ezra Shapiro (USA)
Maurreen Skowran (USA)
Mac Slocum (USA)
Fons Tuinstra (China)
Monique van Dusseldorp (Netherlands)
Peter M. Zollman (USA)
  Site Map | Advertise | Search | Contact | FAQ | Our Guidelines QuickLink  
  Copyright © 1995-2008 The Poynter Institute
  801 Third Street South | St. Petersburg, FL 33701 | Phone (888) 769-6837
  Site developed & hosted by DataGlyphics, Inc.



Poynter Career Center
Thursday: When Should Intern Start Job Search?
Retaining Top Performers During Difficult Times