Poynter Online Poynter Online
New UserLogin
About
About me
E-mail me
Subscribe to this blog's feed
Subscribe to this blog's e-mail newsletter

Columns
  • "Chip on Your Shoulder"
    Poynter Online columns from Nov. 2002-Current
    • Books
    • Reporting and Writing: Basics for the 21st Century
    • America's Best Newspaper Writing-New 2nd Edition
    • The Holly Wreath Man - A Novel
      • Essays, Memoir
      • My cancer time bomb
      • Leave Me Alone, AARP
      • The Hardest Habit to Kick: A Confession
        Audio: A commentary on National Public Radio
      • "The Only Honest Man"
      • "Reading the Paper"
      • "Made in the Shade"
        A package on Southern writers: profiles, interviews and an 11-state directory of writers you may never have heard of but are worth your time. Appeared in Creative Loafing chain.
      • "Mass Appeal"
        A day-in-the-life profile of a telegenic parish priest in Miami. Published in Catholic Digest, reprinted in the St. Petersburg Times
      • "The Liberation of Tam Minh Pham"
        How the first West Point graduate from South Vietnam disappears after the fall of Saigon, only to be rescued by his classmates two decades later. A cover story in The Washington Post Magazine
        • Fiction
        • "The Needle" - A Work in Progress
          Battling for Men's Minds
        • "Mad Looper"
          A Caddy's Life
          • NewsU Courses
          • Get me Rewrite: The Craft of Revision
          • The Lead Lab
          • The Interview



          • The Mechanic & The Muse
            An owner's manual for writers by Chip Scanlan

            Add/View All The Mechanic & The Muse Feedback

            Netting Plagiarists
            The roots of the word plagiarism lie in the Latin noun "plaga" used to describe a net employed by kidnapper to steal children.

            Today plagiarists use an electronic version of a plaga, netting others prose with the cut and paste functions on their word processors.

            But now those trying to snare wordnappers in the newsroom, classroom and the scholarly academy are equipped with an electronic net of their own.

            Battleships rely on shakedown cruises, inaugural voyages designed to uncover mechanical and other problems that only come to light when the ship is at seaa. Programmers do the same, releasing beta versions of software intended to root out bugs and glitches, and often engaging users to help them in the search.

            Check out "Plagiarism 2.0," by Gadi Dechter in The Baltimore City Paper to learn about illuminating shakedown cruises of Lexis-Nexis CopyGuard to detect plagiarism, in this case commited by ousted columnist Michael Olesker, and then by the City Paper.

            Journalists normally recoil at any assault on their First Amendment rights, fearing a "chilling effect" that may hinder their work to inform the citizenry.

            But CopyGuard may produce a similar effect, given its ability to to compare allegedly purloined prose with, as Dechter describes it, "more than 6.1 billion documents in LexisNexis and web databases, and then identifies any matching phrases and their respective sources."

            Anything that might slow a writer's decision to plagiarize or to be less careful about habits that make it happen is one chilling effect that is a positive development for writers, like Olesker and other plagiarists, whose fact is often the corporate equivalent of the death penalty.

            There may be another chilling effect: LexisNexis won't say how much it costs, which I assume means it's pricey and may be out of reach for budget-stretched newsrooms.

            Posted at 12:35:01 PM

            E-mail this item | Add Your Comments | QuickLink this item: A97193


            The Mechanic & The Muse Archive
            View items published between:   and   
            (MM/DD/YYYY) (MM/DD/YYYY)

            | Back to Top



            Search Poynter Online
            Search Poynter Online

            Looking at 'The Bottom Line': Lessons from a Photo Essay
            Looking at 'The Bottom Line': Lessons from a Photo Essay
            New On Poynter
            Your Elevator Speech
            by Jill Geisler

            War Coverage
            What do readers want?

            Fireworks Shortage
            Al's Tuesday Meeting

            More Alzheimer's Cases
            Al's Tuesday Meeting

            Lester's No-Hitter
            Page One Today

            BlogHer Meets Obama
            By Kim Pearson

            Spotty Pet Microchips
            Al's Monday Meeting

            A Case for Subsidies?
            By Rick Edmonds

            Taking a Grammar Vote
            By Roy Peter Clark

            Covering Disabilities
            By Susan LoTempio

            Favorite Blogs, Sites
          • 43 Folders
            43 Folders is Merlin Mann’s entertaining and motivational site about personal productivity, life hacks, and simple ways to make your life a little better
          • Boing Boing: A Directory of Wonderful Things
          • Most E-Mailed Articles - The New York Times - Past 24 Hours
          • Powell's Books
            Author Interviews, Readings
          • Lifehacker, the Productivity and Software Guide
          • Creating Passionate Users
            Metacognitive explorer.
          • First Draft by Tim Porter
          • Online Journalism Review
          • David Allen
          • Gangrey.com
            Keeping Newspapers Alive with Great Storytelling
          • gladwell dot com - malcolm gladwell, blink, tipping point and new yorker articles
          • robcurley.com
          • CyberJournalist.net: How technology, blogs and the Internet are changing the media
            Online journalism pioneer
          • The Rhetorica Network: Analysis of Rhetoric, Propaganda, and Spin in Politics and Journalism
          • Notes from a Teacher: Mark on Media
          • Sree.net: Sreenath Sreenivasan
            A generous and web-savvy friend
          • The New Yorker: Main: Start
            Always check Sunday night for selections of the week's issues posted online
          •   Site Map | Advertise | Search | Contact | FAQ | Our Guidelines QuickLink  
              Copyright © 1995-2008 The Poynter Institute
              801 Third Street South | St. Petersburg, FL 33701 | Phone (888) 769-6837
              Site developed & hosted by DataGlyphics, Inc.



            Poynter Career Center
            Tuesday: Color Paper in Portfolio?
            Giving Credit Costs Little