Poynter Online Poynter Online
New UserLogin
Poynter Online Main Page
Poynter Career Center
Design / Graphics
Diversity
Ethics
Leadership
Online
Photojournalism
Writing / Editing
TV / Radio
Journalism & Business Values
About Poynter
Seminars
Faculty
Columns
Resource Center
The Poynter Store

Help Poynter


Create Your Personal Page
Add Your Bio
Add Your Photo
Share Your Favorite Links

Signup for Poynter Newsletters
Get Poynter Delivered to Your PDA

ASNE Online Ethics Tool



Ask the Recruiter
Joe Grimm of the Detroit Free Press tackles journalism's toughest recruiting questions.

Add/View All Ask the Recruiter Feedback
More Ask the Recruiter

Thursday, January 11, 2007


Get My TV Firing Explained?
Note from Joe: I turned this one over to Scott Libin of the leadership and management faculty at The Poynter Institute. He graciously agreed to help.

I was terminated two months ago at a TV station after nine years on the assignment desk.

In August I received a good review and a modest raise. Later in the month, my wife had cancer surgery.

ASK JOE A QUESTION

To get your question answered on this page, send it to Joe. Please include your full name in your message. If you prefer that your surname not be published, please indicate that.

Sign up to receive Ask The Recruiter by e-mail:
* Click here (sent Monday-Friday at 8 a.m.)

Two days prior to my termination, I asked for time off (which I was owed) to be with her during her chemotherapy, which was scheduled for December.
 
That time off would have been through the end of the year (a time when many news people use up their vacation time also).

The reason I was told I was let go dealt with a decision I made that a producer didn't agree with concerning who would get which live unit for a newscast.

The 5 p.m. producer wanted our big unit (so the reporter could edit her package at the scene), but ended up with a portable unit, because the 6 p.m. producer needed the bigger unit for a live shot in his show that was farther away and couldn't be done with a portable unit.

The newscasts went off without a hitch as far as I could tell, but the next day I was told I was let go without the news director giving me a chance to tell my side of the story. I'm having difficulty dealing with this and really don't know the real reason I was let go.

The company I worked for was "self-insured" when it came to health insurance. They already paid for my wife's surgery, and was now informed of the needed chemotherapy.

The company did not fight my claim for unemployment and even gave me extra severance pay I did not expect.

Is there any legal remedy here? How do I deal with this when applying for other jobs?

Right now, the only work I can get is part time as an on-air announcer at a small-market radio station. I'm afraid my career may be over. I've been in broadcasting since 1981.

Any thoughts on this?

Terminated

You're in a tough situation personally and professionally. Your wife's health crisis would be difficult under any circumstances, and I can imagine it's a lot tougher on both of you now.

No one at Poynter can offer you any legal advice. We aren't qualified, but you might well want to consult an attorney who knows employment law in your state. As a former news director who now trains newsroom managers, I can offer you this much:

Scott Libin
Scott Libin
If you are unclear about the real reasons for your termination, I think you should ask for clarification. Your August review and raise would not preclude your being fired for performance reasons in December, but your side of the story about the incident involving equipment doesn't quite add up. If the newscasts were unaffected and the episode was a "first offense," it does not seem to me like the kind of thing that generally gets people fired. Your letter seems to indicate that you suspect your wife's medical condition had something to do with it. I hope that's not the case, and I have trouble imagining that any successful company would jettison a valued employee solely to avoid the costs involved in his wife's medical condition. (Would you really want to work for such a company anyway?)

You might consider requesting a meeting with your former news director. Ask for no more than 30 minutes. I think it's fair to seek a better understanding of the grounds for your termination, if only to determine how it might affect your future employment. What will the news director say if someone calls for a reference? How can you ensure that your account and the station's do not contradict each other with any prospective employer? These are legitimate issues for discussion, in my opinion.

Be aware that your news director and his or her bosses will be very sensitive to the possibility that you are preparing a lawsuit, even if it turns out you don't have firm legal grounds to sue, or don't want to. They might even decline to meet with you for that reason, or without giving a reason, and I'm sorry to say I don't think you have any way to force such a meeting -- short of suing, that is, and doing that would dramatically change everything about your relationship with the station. If you can't arrange a meeting, a phone conversation or exchange of correspondence might be the best you can do. You might well find that the station's lawyers advise it to say nothing further at all.

Maybe most important, I think you need to answer a few questions for yourself: What do you hope to accomplish? Reinstatement? Is that at all realistic? If not, what would be a more reasonable goal? My suggestion would be to learn whatever you can about what really went wrong, so that in the short term you can adjust your job-search strategy accordingly, and in the long run, you can be even better prepared for whatever challenges might lie ahead.

Best of luck.


Coming Friday: His best reference has left the newspaper, and he now wonders whether he can still use that editor.

 


Posted by Joe Grimm 12:00:00 AM
E-mail this item | Add/View Feedback (1) | QuickLink this item: A116171



Ask the Recruiter Archive
View items published between:   and   
(MM/DD/YYYY) (MM/DD/YYYY)

MAIN | Back to Top




Search Poynter Online
Search Poynter Online

My Boss Likes Me, He Likes Me Not
My Boss Likes Me, He Likes Me Not
New On Poynter
A Case for Subsidies?
By Rick Edmonds

Whither Bush's Blog?
By Alan Abbey

Olympian Ruling
Al's Friday Meeting

Tech-Savvy Cities
Al's Friday Meeting

Taking a Grammar Vote
By Roy Peter Clark

Covering Disabilities
By Susan LoTempio

News from Israel
Page One Today

Where's Joe?

  • June 1-4, Washington, D.C.
  • June 8, Grand Rapids, AAJA-Michigan photo auction
  • July 23-27, UNITY 2008, Chicago
  • Sept. 10-13, Online News Association, D.C.
Give Me a Sign

As we travel our career paths, wondering where to go next, we get signs. They can be in places ordinary or unexpected. They can come from above or from the road commission. We use those signs in Ask the Recruiter.

If you see a sign that speaks to you about your career, e-mail a photo of it to joe.grimm@gmail.com. Who knows? The sign you see may serve another.
  Site Map | Advertise | Search | Contact | FAQ | Our Guidelines QuickLink  
  Copyright © 1995-2008 The Poynter Institute
  801 Third Street South | St. Petersburg, FL 33701 | Phone (888) 769-6837
  Site developed & hosted by DataGlyphics, Inc.



Poynter Career Center
Friday: Can New Media Save My Career?
Giving Credit Costs Little