Poynter Online
Go


Top Story

Young Journalists Use Facebook Ads to Reach Prospective Employers
Most Recent Articles
Most E-mailed
Recent Comments
Recent Tags
Community Activity

Poynter Training
Poynter Seminars
Small, in-person training experiences.
News University
Today's most popular courses on NewsU, Poynter's e-learning site for journalists.
Webinars
Our online classroom is just a click away. Learn more.
All Webinars

Poynter Forums

Keeping Up With Weblogs

Page 1 of 1 
More thoughts
6/6/2002 7:12:25 PM
Posted By: Rick Brown


Thank you for shedding light on the topic. You're right; I see in the user agreement that account
sharing is allowed. Obviously, you've done nothing wrong or unauthorized. However,
I wonder if the NYT really thought about this type of mass use when they wrote that clause.
It's one thing to share a log-in with a few friends and another to have MSNBC (or any well-read blog)
distributing it. Of course, if it's technically impossible or impractical to prevent multiple simultaneous
log-ins from one account, it serves little purpose to prohibit it in a written policy. I'm wondering what
use registration is at all on a free site if everyone starts sharing master log-ins like that. This computer
now has the run of the site without independent registration because I told the browser to save the
Hardball log-in cookie. The Times marketing department surely wouldn't view that as a positive
development.

Also, by broadcasting its user name and password, you have made your account unsecure. How long
before someone "updates" the password just to mess with your users? It seems the only way to avoid that
problem is to go back to not giving out a "master" log-in or to arrange a specific deal for easy access
with the Times.




Thank you Mr. Brown (account sharing)
6/6/2002 5:58:58 PM
Posted By: Will Femia

To be honest, I'd seen the pre-arranged login and password in other blogs before setting it up for the Chris Matthews blog http://chrismatthews.msnbc.com (and also for Altercation, http://altercation.msnbc.com the Eric Alterman blog). To answer your initial question, the NY Times does allow this account sharing (see section 6 of their subscriber agreement http://www.nytimes.com/ref/membercenter/help/agree.html).

On the other hand, such a thing would not be allowed for a site like the Wall Street Journal which charges a subscription fee (NYT is free). Section 5a of their Subscriber Agreement makes that explicitly clear. http://online.wsj.com/subscriber_agreement

-Will Femia, MSNBC.com weblog producer




Blogs sharing user log-ins
6/6/2002 3:54:32 AM
Posted By: Rick Brown


I spotted something interesting while checking the links on this item. Web logs or other
aggregators who promote password sharing may impact site registration. Take a look at
Chris Matthew's weblog at http://www.msnbc.com/news/751547.asp. Note that in the item,
"Let's Make a Deal" for June 5, that he has a link to a New York Times article. Next to the
link, it says: "Registration is required for this NYT link. Login: HardballMSNBC Password:
Hardball." What a neat way to bypass the time-consuming process of registration to read
one lousy article.

However, did the NYT authorize this "master" log-in or did Matthews do it on his own? If the
NYT hasn't agreed to this type of mass log-in, they might react rather negatively, possibly
invalidating that user account, or ensuring that multiple simultaneous log-ins aren't possible
with the same account, or filing a lawsuit. If bloggers start sharing log-in info, which seems
like a logical thing to do for the sake of convenience, it's going to reduce the accuracy of
information gathered by any free registration system that allows multiple simultaneous log-ins
with the same account. I wonder how difficult it is technically to prohibit that.

On the other hand, a newspaper that views blog links as a blessing could conceivably fine-tune its
registration process to allow authorized bloggers to link to specific articles without requiring
time-consuming registration of the reader. Or maybe certain specialized blogs might want to offer
a "one-registration-fits-all" to its readers in conjunction with cooperating linked sources. (If you
register at John Doe's Home Gardening Blog, you're automatically registered at its most commonly
linked sources without filling out further forms. In exchange for cooperating with the blog, the
newspaper sites get registration data that identifies the home gardening interests of the readers
of that specialized blog.)



Page 1 of 1 
Return to Previous Page

Username
Password
New User? Signup Now
Poynter Careers
More media jobs