Huffington Post removes Liane Membis piece it says was fabricated

The Atlantic Wire | Yale Daily News | The Clarion-Ledger
Alexander Abad-Santos reports The Huffington Post removed an article by Liane Membis, who lost her Wall Street Journal internship last month because she fabricated quotes.

Membis’ HuffPo piece was republished from The New Journal at Yale, where it’s still online. It’s about a 2010 Yale grad and undocumented immigrant Membis called Teresa Serrano, saying she’d changed her subject’s name to protect her.

The editor’s note says The Huffington Post removed the piece after investigating and finding “sources in the original piece denied having made statements attributed to them by the author; other attributed statements in the piece could not be independently confirmed.” Santos notes the banality of quotes from Membis’ subject:

Like the quotes that got Membis fired from The Wall Street Journal, they’re pretty ho-hum and forgettable, but they’re also tailor-made for a story about “Serrano”‘s struggle.

In an interview with the Yale Daily News, Membis said her Wall Street Journal fabulism was an “an honest reporting mistake that I made,” and that “This is definitely something I’ve never done before.”

The “honest” part of that is a little hard to swallow. In an open letter to Membis, the great Jerry Mitchell muses about the “baffling” nature of her transgressions.

If you had actually taken the time to talk to real people in the neighborhood, you would have gotten far better quotes than the ones you decided to concoct.

That’s what’s so vexing about this whole Membis business: Why did she throw away her career for such minor stuff?

Also, the pieces Membis wrote for CNN are still up. CNN still hasn’t replied to my query about whether it is looking into them.

Previously: Wall Street Journal intern fired for fabricating sources

We have made it easy to comment on posts, however we require civility and encourage full names to that end (first initial, last name is OK). Please read our guidelines here before commenting.

  • Anonymous

    This is not so unusual. A lot of people like the idea of being a reporter and writer, but they don’t like the business of going out and finding people and talking to them.

  • Anonymous

    NP: go figured what? barnicle just might have been caught up in internal politics and railroaded by the globe. somebody wrote a long piece some years ago that indicated as much. and who knows what the wsj intern will be doing 10 years from now?

  • http://twitter.com/NaomiPierce Naomi Pierce

    They fire WSJ intern for fabricating quotes, but Mike Barnicle ex of the Boston Globe is now a vaunted commentator on MSNBC. Go figure.