Another false quotation found in Jonah Lehrer’s ‘Imagine’

The Skeptical Libertarian
Teller, of the Penn & Teller magician duo, joins Bob Dylan as a famous person who didn’t say what Jonah Lehrer quoted him as saying in his book “Imagine.” Here’s what Lehrer claimed Teller said in 1981:

“I was definitely on the verge of giving up the dream of becoming a magician … I was ready to go back home and become a high-school Latin teacher.”

Kevin Breen thought that from Teller sounded suspicious, in part because it contradicted another Teller quotation in a story Lehrer wrote for Wired in 2009. So this week, Breen drove from Los Angeles to Las Vegas to ask Teller about it in person.

I read Teller his quote from the Wired article: “I always assumed I’d spend my life happily performing in artsy-fartsy little theaters,” before asking him about the contradictory quote in Lehrer’s book.

“That’s correct,” Teller confirmed, before pointing to the fabricated quote from Imagine, “This is not.”

There is another similarity between the fake quotations ascribed to Teller and Dylan: Both were discovered by people who are serious fans of the people being quoted.I’m something of the Dylan obsessive,” wrote Michael Moynihan in his story detailing his quest to substantiate the Dylan quotes.

Likewise, Breen tells me by email:

Yeah, I’m kind of a Penn and Teller nerd. I tend to watch/read/listen to just about everything they put out. I only have one magnet on my refrigerator, and it’s an autographed Penn and Teller magnet I bought after one of their shows.

So there’s your fabrication detection software: rabid fans.

Related: Time columnist Fareed Zakaria suspended for lifting from New Yorker story

Earlier: Jonah Lehrer’s publisher is reviewing all of his booksPlagiarism, more fake interviews in Jonah Lehrer’s booksWNYC: No reason to believe that Jonah Lehrer’s work for ‘Radiolab’ is compromisedJayson Blair on Jonah Lehrer fabrications: ‘There’s probably more than what we’ve seen so far’

We have made it easy to comment on posts, however we require civility and encourage full names to that end (first initial, last name is OK). Please read our guidelines here before commenting.

  • Anonymous

    What’s your point?  Are you alleging a secret (rabid!) libertarian cabal to bring down Lehrer?  That it’s OK to fudge banal quotes if only libertarians notice?  That it’s wrong to both complain about Comedy Central and point out fabrications?  Your comments seems to be a hodgepodge of stuff aimed at basically saying you don’t like libertarians.

  • http://twitter.com/Rosemar05180095 Rosemarie

    ….
    goo.gl/Qqif3

  • http://twitter.com/Rosemar05180095 Rosemarie

    Vincent responded I am impressed that any body can profit $4266 in a few weeks on the network. did you see this(Click on menu Home)

  • http://twitter.com/Rosemar05180095 Rosemarie

    Vincent responded I am impressed that any body can profit $4266 in a few weeks on the network. did you see this(Click on menu Home)

  • http://www.poynter.org Poynter

    Hi, Esmertina. I’ve fixed that link. It should go here: http://journ.us/Q5RiMd –Julie Moos, Director of Poynter Online

  • http://twitter.com/Esmertina Esmertina Bicklesnit

    You have a self-referencing link in your first paragraph — where is it supposed to go?

  • http://twitter.com/JulietWaters Juliet Waters

    Although they Moynihan, Keen, and Teller do share one other thing in common.  They’re all rabid, professional libertarians.  I’d be really surprised if they didn’t know each other.  Though it seems to be the kind of libertarianism that goes ballistic when Comedy Central censors parodies of Muhhamed, but celebrates getting books pulled out of stores based on  the fudging of  banal quotes.  Very odd.

  • http://www.granitegeek.org DaveBrooks

    The takehome lesson: Only make up quotes from unknown people. 

  • Anonymous

    These lies by Lehrer are shameful and insulting.