Did ‘podunk’ location mean Alabama hostage crisis got less media coverage?

Chicago Sun-Times | Our Man in Chicago
Sun-Times digital editor Marcus Gilmer writes that had the hostage crisis that just ended in Alabama “happened in a large city – New York, Dallas, even, God forbid, Chicago – the coverage would be constant, a 24-hour surveillance with every media outlet descending on the city.”

Jimmy Lee Dykes allegedly stormed a schoolbus, shot its driver and took a 5-year-old boy hostage in an underground bunker for days. Agents stormed the bunker and killed Dykes on Monday. What more did cable news need?

The police had asked representatives of local media outlets to keep as much of a lid on the story as they could, Gilmer allows, but he says that still doesn’t explain its second-banana status in the national news cycle. Sun-Times readers weren’t rabid consumers of news about the standoff, he notes:

It’s hard to imagine someone in Chicago, a city plagued by its own problems of violence and innocent victims, caring much about what they perceive is some crazy redneck with a shotgun in some podunk Alabama town. (To be fair, my following of the case was heightened by the fact I’m an Alabama native.) …

And while we certainly saw a bump in readership on the stories about the Midland crisis posted on our website, it still didn’t overcome the amount of readers heading towards other stories, both understandable (Hadiya Pendleton) and trivial (anything involving Super Bowl commercials).

Undeniably, a heavily populated metropolitan area teeming with journalists would produce more coverage of a bizarre crime like the one allegedly perpetrated in Midland City, Ala.

The Dothan (Ala.) Eagle had what appears to be the first print hit on the story. That paper is owned by Berkshire Hathaway. Advance’s three Alabama newspapers, the closest of which is 190 miles away, followed within hours. The crisis began on Jan. 29 and competed for media oxygen with the Super Bowl, immigration reform and — yep — gun violence in Chicago. In fact, the type of coverage Gilmer thinks would have been appropriate might well have produced an opposite reaction — Why are we spending so much time on a story with so few updates?

Here are some of the daily headlines from the crisis:

Jan. 30: “Alabama hostage crisis continues; 5-year-old victim still locked in bunker

Jan. 31: “No change this morning as the Midland City hostage situation enters its 40th hour

Feb. 1: “Hostage negotiators proceeding carefully

Feb. 2: “In Midland City hostage standoff, a fifth day, and no change

Feb. 3: Ala. Sheriff: Boy held dostage in bunker has toys

With updates like that, can you imagine the tenor of more coverage? Scott Smith has some ideas about why this standoff didn’t dominate the news for a week. Here’s one more: The Alabama story, though bizarre, sadly has plenty of competition for a national conversation-starter on guns. Slate has compiled a database of gun deaths in the U.S. since Newtown. At the time I write this, it records 23 kids as having been killed by gun violence after that incident.

Related: Brief history of long-running police standoffs (AP)

We have made it easy to comment on posts, however we require civility and encourage full names to that end (first initial, last name is OK). Please read our guidelines here before commenting.

  • http://rtberner.blogspot.com/ R Thomas Berner

    This is not news. It happens all the time. I remember when an earthquake struck in Elko County, Nevada, several years ago and CNN referred to the area as isolated to explain the lack of video. My wife and I laughed. We’ve been there often to visit family. Interstate 80 cuts through Elko County. It’s isolated only if you’ve never been there.

  • http://www.facebook.com/Patrick.Jean Patrick Jean

    All the easier to make our first domestic drone kill with, my dear. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8FjoIL3ObYI

  • http://twitter.com/angelialevy Angelia N. Levy

    Just like the old real estate adage “location, location, location” – the same applied to this story as far as mainstream media was concerned. I’m not saying that the media should’ve or needed to
    provide wall-to-wall coverage ala Newtown or Virginia Tech. However, their coverage of this SEVEN-DAY hostage crisis was pretty anemic. It was almost Groundhog-like, news would pop up for a few minutes then disappear for days. Maybe the limited/muted coverage was also due to journalistic fear that media would go overboard like it did with Newtown where unsubstantiated/non-fact checked information (i.e. journalism failure re Ryan Lanza Facebook page, dad was killed, etc.) made it onto the airwaves and the internet as factual news. Plus, we are now in a post-Newtown world in re to traumatic gun violence stories. Cynically, two deaths anywhere, especially in Alabama verses the death of over 20 kids at a school house in a suburban town near a major news metropolitan area (NY) just doesn’t make the media sensationalism grade.

  • JH

    This is completely true. Good luck getting anyone to care about your tornado or shooting the way New York media cared about Hurricane Sandy or Newtown.