The Daily Caller’s Menendez prostitution ‘scoop’ unravels

The Daily Caller, Tucker Carlson’s conservative version of Huffington Post, is at the center of a media controversy. And loving it.

In November, the Caller published a story based on two anonymous Dominican women claiming that New Jersey Sen. Robert Menendez had paid them for sex.

ABC News says it received similar information at the same time, as Republican operatives organized interviews with those two women, plus a third woman the Caller did not talk to, all of whom said the senator paid them for sex. But ABC News didn’t run with the story, because “none of the women could produce identity cards with their names, and they all provided the same story almost word for word, as if they had been coached.”

After the Caller’s story was published, things started to unravel.

The Miami Herald scoured the Dominican Republic and found no sign of the women and no evidence.

The Washington Post reported this week that one of the three women swore in an affidavit that it was all a set up. The women were paid to use fake names and pass a fake story to the media.

ABC News confirms that woman was one of the three sources that made the allegations.

The Caller’s statement and a follow-up article written by Executive Editor David Martosko say the woman wasn’t one of its two sources. However, it acknowledged there was a third woman present during its webcam interview who did not get to talk before a laptop battery died.

The Caller stands by its reports, though apparently doesn’t feel the need to prove its allegations right, just to claim that doubters haven’t conclusively proven them wrong. Slate’s David Weigel calls it “a deductive, prove-this-wrong-why-don’t-you theory of the scoop.”

Carlson, meanwhile, seems happy his business is in the spotlight. In an interview with The Washington Post’s Paul Farhi on Tuesday, Carlson said: “Oh, it’s a very good day. It’s a good day because it’s an interesting day.”

And of his critics, Carlson said: “I’m not seeking their approval. Why should I care if a bunch of losers on Twitter don’t like it?”

Farhi notes this has been part of the Caller’s recipe for success:

The put-up-your-dukes attitude has made the Daily Caller a rising star among the new Washington media, particularly the conservative kind. … One of its first attention-grabbing stories was its reporting in 2010 on Journolist, an e-mail group started by Post blogger Ezra Klein in which reporters privately trashed various politicians, most of them conservative.

The outfit again caused a stir when its White House reporter, Neil Munro, interrupted President Obama’s remarks about immigration last year. …

But other Caller “scoops” have fizzled. Carlson went on Fox News last year to hype a 2007 video of Obama praising his former pastor, the Rev. Jeremiah Wright, and suggesting that the federal government had shortchanged African American victims of Hurricane Katrina. Despite build-up for the video from the Drudge Report and Fox’s Sean Hannity, it caused barely a ripple. Most of its content had been reported on before — by, among others, Carlson.

We have made it easy to comment on posts, however we require civility and encourage full names to that end (first initial, last name is OK). Please read our guidelines here before commenting.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/John-Avignone/100001760784049 John Avignone

    New brand of journalism? There’s nothing new about it. Yellow journalism has been alive and well in the US since day 1. Jefferson even went so far as to secretly buy a newspaper and hire a guy to write false stories – horrible stuff – to smear John Adams. In the end it backfired. The guy Jefferson hired to plant false stories about Adams a few years later broke the real story of Jefferson and his slave, Sally Hemmings.

    The Wingnutosphere is getting more and more strident for a simple reason. They’re dying. Literally. The base of the conservative movement – old white people – is dying off. Those replacing them are far more diverse and do not share their predecessors’ bigotry and ignorance. I consider the wingnut howls of poutrage to be a positive sign. They’re screaming in pain.

  • http://www.cafepress.com/bulliesforromney Bullies For Romney

    The RightWingNut Republican media operates in it’s own, biosphere, echo chamber bubble in where the only time it’s reporting crosses over to the credible legacy and mainstream media is when the credible legacy and mainstream can longer ignore the blatant and slanderous lies and in-your-face, outright egregious deceptiveness.

  • addalled

    Obama’s 2007 Hampton speech may have been reported but I definitely don’t remember the networks playing the “Where’s yo Stafford money?’ part.

  • addalled

    Sex with a minor is illegal even if it occurred overseas.

  • Nicholas

    Wow, is it possible for Tucker Carlson to become more of a D*ck?

  • LutherPoach

    I hope this new brand of “journalism” doesn’t catch on. This incident reminds me of that criminal fraud guy who did the ACORN videos, which were deceptively edited, yet people lost their jobs and had their reputations smeared for things they didn’t do. His NPR “sting” was also fraudulent. Amazingly, it was Glenn Beck’s website that was responsible for exposing the NPR sting as fraudulent. I didn’t expect Tucker Carlson to stoop to this level. Hopefully, this won’t be a trend.

  • BrotherMatthias

    Did the FBI investigation of Menendez also unravel? Prostitution is legal in the DR, so the claim was never too much of a worry for me.