Ohio University journalism students may go on Brazil trip sponsored by U.S. Soccer

Plans for students at Ohio University’s journalism school to travel with the U.S. Soccer Team to Brazil for the 2014 World Cup, writing for and about the team, may come undone thanks to the students’ tenacity.

On Monday, students in the E.W. Scrippps School of Journalism learned of the trip and a lot of them tweeted about it. On Wednesday, several students contacted the U.S. Soccer Federation to start asking questions, Bob Stewart, director of the journalism school, told Poynter by phone. And now, the U.S. Soccer Federation wants to take a breath.

“They’re actually saying, let’s slow down a little bit,” Stewart said. They do, after all, have a World Cup Soccer team to pull together, he added.

The program seemed a sure thing Monday when the school held a press conference announcing the team-school partnership. In retrospect, it may have been a bit premature, says Yusuf Kalyango, director of the International Institute of Journalism at OU.

“It is still in the works, actually,” Kalyango told Poynter. “There has been a lot of excitement from our students.” But nothing is yet confirmed, he said, and the whole thing could fall through.

Journalism students being journalism students ran with the story and contacted the federation for details, resulting in the loud sound of brakes being applied.

Kalyango did hold the press conference with journalism students, but he didn’t expect them, or the journalism school, to then report on it. And they did.

But so did Kalyango, who tweeted the deal was official and confirmed on Oct. 31.

Poynter contacted the school on Tuesday with questions about the nature of the work proposed. Preliminary plans called for 10 students to travel from the U.S. to Brazil, for which the students would pay. But they would then get free tickets to games with the U.S. team and free chartered air travel within Brazil with the team.

In addition, the school said:

While in Brazil, students will have full access to the U.S. Soccer players, coaches, executives and family members, and will assist the U.S. Soccer Federation with all the logistics of holding daily press conferences and briefings. They will tweet, write stories, shoot videos, take photos, and post on Facebook and other media sites administered by U.S. Soccer. They also will occasionally provide human-interest stories to the IIJ Blog, the international student-news blog of the E. W. Scripps School of Journalism.

Feeding the U.S. Soccer’s Twitter account and other media sites wouldn’t be a problem for students in the school’s public relations (Strategic Communication) track, but poses ethical issues for the student journalists.

“About one-third of the students in the E.W. Scripps School of Journalism are studying Strategic Communication, and two-thirds are studying News & Information. All students are eligible to apply for this program. No doubt, some of the students selected will be from the Strategic Communication track,” Stewart said in an e-mail to Poynter on Wednesday.

“There’s definitely a strategic communications element to it,” he added today.

Details are still being worked out, but the U.S. Soccer Federation will choose the students and oversee the content the students produce.

Stewart said if The New York Times wanted to take 10 students to Brazil and give them this opportunity, that would be great. But there are fewer and fewer opportunities for students now, “so our job is to try to give students as many diverse opportunities as possible.”

Even if student news reporters don’t go into PR, it may be helpful for them to see that side of the business, he said.

If they get to go, Kalyango said he’ll have full details by Dec. 3. So far, Stewart said, no student journalists had raised concerns about the program.

We have made it easy to comment on posts, however we require civility and encourage full names to that end (first initial, last name is OK). Please read our guidelines here before commenting.

  • breader

    It is unfair and unethical itself to level an allegation that there is some “ethical” impropriety with such an educational opportunity. College students are just that — students — who are free to take courses outside of their major areas of study or to get involved in activities that aren’t within the “bubbles” of their chosen majors.

    In the case of students interested in sports journalism, it would be foolish for them to not also take some courses about sports administration and marketing.

    Would Ms. Hare’s narrow (and, apparently, ignorant) beliefs about “journalism ethics” prohibit journalism students who want to become political analysts and commentators from taking political science courses or accepting internships with governmental agencies? Or students who want to cover the arts from accepting internships working in the marketing and communication departments of philharmonics, theatre companies, film studios, etc.?

    Our students are smart enough to know the difference between “news journalism” and “advocacy,” and know that there are certain ethical expectations and limitations depending on the jobs they accept. But they don’t have to adhere to some arbitrary, puritanical dogma while attending college and figuring out their future career goals.

    Ms. Hare’s implication that the proposed partnership has “ethical issues” for our “journalism” students is unfair, uninformed, and itself fraught with ethical lapses. We are owed a clarification, at minimum, and an apology would also not be out of line.

    – Bill Reader, associate professor, E.W. Scripps School of Journalism
    co-author with Steven Knowlton, “Moral Reasoning for Journalists” (Praeger, 2008)

  • ProSoccerCoaching

    This is a great venture. The more the US learns about soccer coaching and style of play of other countries the better off the grass roots and national team will be in the long run. Well done US Soccer. Keep investing and it will pay dividend eventually. Soccer Coaching and Education