News orgs repeat but don’t check reports of Egyptian necrophilia law

Did you hear that Egypt’s Parliament is working on a law that would allow husbands to have sex with their deceased wives?

This idea appeared in an opinion piece published in Al Ahram, Egypt’s state newspaper. From there it spread, thanks to the Daily Mail’s website and Huffington Post, according to a report in the Christian Science Monitor that says the so-called “farewell intercourse law” is a red herring.

Andrew Sullivan also linked to the Daily Mail story, thus adding credibility to the report. Update: His site has a follow up post that does a good job breaking down the concerns about the Mail story and the supposed legislation.

Many other sites still have reports up about the law that don’t include any hedging or updates about claims that it was planted as a way to discredit Egypt’s new government.

The Huffington Post has updated its story to note some claim the story is false. Strangely the update only links to the Twitter account of one person, and not to any specific tweet by her. (She previously tweeted that HuffPost would not publish her comments on the story.)

The Daily Mail’s story has also been updated, though it still carries a declarative headline: “Outrage as Egypt plans ‘farewell intercourse law’ so husbands can have sex with DEAD wives up to six hours after their death.”

The Mail piece now includes a bit of hedging in the lead: “Egyptian husbands will soon be legally allowed to have sex with their dead wives for up to six hours after their death, local media is claiming.”

But that wasn’t there when it was published yesterday morning.

“Egyptian husbands will soon be legally allowed to have sex with their dead wives – for up to six hours after their death,” was how it read.

The story also now includes these details at the bottom of the piece:

Although reported in local media, there are some suggestions from within Egypt that the plans do not exist and were merely seeded by journalists loyal to ousted President Hosni Mubarak.

MailOnline has contacted the Egyptian Embassy and Consulate in London for comment on the claimed proposals, and is yet to receive a reply.

Hopefully some credible information about this legislation, if indeed it exists, will be forthcoming.

We have made it easy to comment on posts, however we require civility and encourage full names to that end (first initial, last name is OK). Please read our guidelines here before commenting.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Prakash-Sarko/1097613984 Prakash Sarko

    Daily (Toilet) Mail Paper now has the habit of posting stupid headlines that mock Muslims, two months back it posted a story that there was an unknown cleric based in Europe, who said that Muslim women shouldn’t touch cucumbers as they are sexually exciting, basing it on an Arabic newspaper in Egypt.

    It was taken to the Press Complaints Commission where it apologised and removed the article from its website, not long before the article had been broadcast many times over in other media basing their reports on Daily (Toilet) Mail UK.

    Daily Fail, as many commentators call this paper, has now published another article that says that “Egypt’s ‘plans for farewell intercourse law so husbands can have sex with DEAD wives’ branded a ‘complete nonsense’ ” even though the language is highly ambiguous it can cover its back.

  • http://www.facebook.com/tina.guthrow Tina Guthrow

    please post an update when it becomes available. Thank you!