AP’s Navy Yard photos unrelated to shooting? D.C. man who says he was in them tells his story

Eric Levenson raises many good questions about two pictures AP pulled from the wire Monday. They purported to show bystanders helping a victim of the Navy Yard shootings. The photographer, Don Andres, told MSNBC: “I don’t know if it’s related” to the violence.

Mandy Jenkins of Digital First Media tweeted her doubts: “Still pretty confused as to how a wounded man was dragged to CVS from the Navy Yard, it’s at least 3 blocks away.” Other questions remained, as well: Why was there no sign of blood? Would people have picked up and moved a gunshot victim to the ground on a concrete street corner?

James Birdsall may hold some answers. Birdsall is a structural engineer at the Parsons Corporation, a firm with an office at 100 M St. SE in Washington, D.C. That’s very close to the CVS in front of which the photos appear to have been taken. Some of his colleagues saw a woman in a violet shirt pull an injured man from her car. Birdsall, who called Poynter to share his story, said he saw that she was performing chest compressions on the man and noticed she didn’t have an automated external defibrillator.

Birdsall grabbed his firm’s AED “and ran over to help out,” he said.

Birdsall was wearing a blue shirt and khaki pants Monday. He sent me a photo of himself after I requested one. His face isn’t visible in the pictures. But his story casts doubt on easy conclusions about the photo’s truth.

When Birdsall arrived with his AED, “It became pretty evident that he was shot,” he said. “He had an entry wound on the left side of his face.”

The woman kept repeating a first name that matches one of the victims as he helped try to revive the man. She was saying the victim’s name “pretty intensely,” he said. She didn’t appear to be a relative but they apparently knew each other.

An ambulance arrived and removed the man. “It seemed like it was driven by cops,” Birdsall said.

A spokesperson for George Washington University Hospital told journalists Monday that a victim who had been shot in the left temple “was pronounced dead within a minute of arriving at George Washington University Hospital,” Michael D. Shear and Michael S. Schmidt reported in The New York Times.

“This injury was not survivable by any stretch,” a hospital official told reporters. “The patient was dead on the way to the hospital.”

Birdsall didn’t get the names of his fellow bystanders. After the ambulance left, he cleaned up some blood-spattered items on the ground, depositing them in the trash. He went back to work and “put in a request for a new AED,” he said.

Don Andres, the passerby who took the photos, works for U.S. Rep. Steven Horsford of Nevada. When I called Horsford’s office earlier this afternoon, the person who answered said Andres was on his way to the bathroom; he has not yet returned my call.

James Birdsall says he’s the man in the blue shirt and khaki trousers in this photo. (Click image to view larger.)
Here’s another photo. Both were taken by Don Andres. (Click image to view larger.)

We have made it easy to comment on posts, however we require civility and encourage full names to that end (first initial, last name is OK). Please read our guidelines here before commenting.

  • http://www.DNotice.org/ Dean Jackson
  • http://www.DNotice.org/ Dean Jackson

    I love it! The new story is even more ludicrous! Couldn’t AP have come up with a non-hilarious narrative in the four-day period that they had to concoct a new story?

    Thanks for the update!

  • http://www.DNotice.org/ Dean Jackson

    There’s nothing AP can say now since George Washington University Hospital already affirmed that the man died of a gunshot to the temple, and the only shootings that took place Monday morning in Washington, DC was at the Navy Yard. The photos will go down the memory hole, along with the two persons arrested at Sandy Hook Elementary.

  • http://www.DNotice.org/ Dean Jackson

    Yes, the behaviors the photos capture are odd, so AP was told to pull them, because no one would accept the odd behaviors I pointed out in my comment.

  • steve849

    So what’s the answer? How about a little additional reporting from the “leader in journalism education?”

  • mrsmurple

    This event is sketchy as HECK.. have you noticed how there is actually no proof of any “victims” of this shooting whatsoever?

    This particular Navy Yard building is surrounded with cameras, and the interior is full of security cameras, as well as every civilian/military person in there having a cell-phone camera on them- yet there are not images at all of any victims, or any “action” inside the building.

    This appears to be yet another gun control hoax..

    Oh, and the “unrelated to Shooting Image” show above- was provided by non other than a government “Communications Director” working for Representative Steven Horsford – a Rep. who of course “Supports restrictions on gun purchases.”

  • http://www.DNotice.org/ Dean Jackson

    The article reads, “A spokesperson for George Washington University Hospital told journalists Monday that a victim who had been shot in the left temple…”

    Birdsall said. “He had an entry wound on the left side of his face.”