November 3, 2026

We need more creative and encouraging editors in journalism. Could you be one of them?

One of the most frequent questions I receive from mid-career journalists is about whether they should make the transition into editing and how to go about doing so.

They wonder if they will be hired despite having no management experience, if they can handle the stress of managing other people’s emotions and careers, if they will miss having a byline and being able to jump on a big story, if they will be forced to sit in meetings all day, and if this is the best way to make more money.

Earlier this month, an excellent science writer with about eight years of reporting experience reached out to ask for advice about how to apply for editing jobs. She asked: What kind of editing role should I pursue? And will anyone hire me even though I’ve never been an editor before?

The short answer is yes. If you are a talented rank-and-file journalist, there’s a chance a manager in your newsroom or elsewhere in the industry is salivating at the idea that you want to step up and take on more responsibility.

Journalism, like many other professions, depends on smooth transitions and succession planning as editors retire, burn out or change careers. We need more leaders with strong news judgment, empathy and coaching skills. But many people tell us no when we try to talk them into becoming managers. They simply love reporting, taking photographs and doing the work themselves too much to give it up.

Still, editors are not magically made in some exclusive graduate program. They come from the rank-and-file staff. Though it might be hard for some people to imagine their formidable editor as a rookie, it is very likely the leader you admire for bringing people together, finessing a lede or inspiring a creative breakthrough was once a junior photographer, copy editor, designer, newsletter writer, metro reporter or something similar.

So how did they get their breakthrough role?

There is no single path into management. Some people are cajoled into it by newsroom leaders scrambling to fill an unexpected vacancy. Others spend years campaigning for a promotion. And some test their curiosity by filling in when an editor goes on vacation or family leave.

A great science reporter can become a successful science team editor. A hard-hitting City Hall reporter might thrive leading the local politics team. The assignment writer with a notepad full of quirky ideas could be a stellar breaking news editor. And the photographer who always gets the best pictures could be just the leader the photography department needs to propel them to new heights.

After years of producing excellent journalism, many journalists have stepped into new roles coaching others, even as they occasionally struggled with some of the not-so-fun managerial aspects of the job. Those responsibilities can range from coaching someone who keeps missing deadlines to turning down a request for a pay increase.

If you are considering moving into editing, share your interest with your manager or a trusted editor or mentor. See if they can explain how your responsibilities might change.

Will someone in your newsroom let you fill in as an editor for at least a few shifts so you can get a taste of what this work entails? Will an editor let you shadow them?

If these opportunities are not being offered to you, ask why.

Perhaps your newsroom needs you to remain in your staff job.

Or maybe you need to develop some of the skills you’ll need as an editor. Do you need to work on turning in cleaner copy? Coming up with sharper story ideas or better newsroom strategies? Mentoring others to gain leadership skills? Working more collaboratively with others?

If you might want to get into management in the near future, consider volunteering for newsroom committees, such as serving as a leader on an inclusion or style committee, or joining a mentoring program. Check in with colleagues who seem eager for more support and guidance. They will often spread the gospel about your coaching to people who have the power to promote you. Show you’re a team player by contributing to major newsroom projects. Make sure your editor supports your involvement and gives you time to take on these additional responsibilities.

Even if you ultimately decide against going into management, you will have strengthened your relationships with your colleagues and learned more about how your newsroom works.

If you are applying for an editor job as an external candidate, you still have a shot. Tell the hiring editor about your experience effectively communicating across news departments, how you assess whether a story is worth pursuing, the scoops you’ve delivered, your approach to everyday tasks and how you would help others do similar work.

If your goal is to make a lot more money, don’t assume an editor job is the only way to do that. Some reporters earn more than their editors and don’t have the same stress of making countless decisions for others every day. Some editors go many years without pay raises, stuck at the salary they were hired at. And if you don’t like managing and helping other people, no paycheck is worth the headache that can come with having to get someone to do something they don’t want to do.

For me, the reward of management is being able to advocate for others. That can look like coaching someone who wants a promotion on how they can make their case to the executive editor. Helping someone refine a pitch and then rallying others behind their big idea. Directing someone toward a fellowship that can help them learn new skills.

I also love having some influence over a news organization’s values. This has allowed me to encourage news teams to embrace more inclusive story ideas and policies; advocate for digital innovation and community building with audiences; and champion better pay and benefits for staffers.

I’ve had some good bosses who never worked as a reporter. But I can’t deny that many of my favorite managers have been people who shared my passion for exceptional reporting and writing. They understood the difficulty of landing a tough interview and shared my love for lyrical ledes and a gut-punch of a kicker.

Over the past decade, as I rose up the ranks of various newsrooms, I have tried to regularly set aside time to coach other former reporters making their way into management. I helped them fill in as an editor when someone was out, let them watch as I edited a story or shared my decision-making process when it came to approving story ideas, hiring and career growth.

After many years in journalism, I will likely always miss having a byline, jetting off to a distant city for a breaking story or a news feature, and talking to people about how government policies are shaping their lives.

But I do get a lot of joy from helping someone step into their power to become the kind of editor we all once dreamed of having: caring, focused, innovative and honest.

And that is worth sitting through a few boring meetings every week.


Want to chat about your career questions? Email me at cristina.silva@globe.com with the subject “Ask the Recruiter.” Questions can be published with your name or anonymously.


Whether you’re searching for your first newsroom job or your next leadership role, the Media Job Board features hundreds of opportunities from news organizations across North America.

This kind of journalism doesn’t fund itself.

Poynter helps you understand what’s happening in the media industry and how it shapes the news you read every day. Donations power our nonprofit newsroom and keep stories like these free for everyone.

DONATE
Cristina Silva is The Boston Globe’s Managing Editor for Operations and Standards, where she helps lead newsroom AI strategy, editorial standards and partnerships. Previously, she…
Cristina Silva

More News

Back to News