Ethical decisions in journalism are rarely black and white. Many fall in a gray zone, where there’s no obvious answer and thoughtful, experienced journalists can disagree about what to do. Those are the calls that tend to reach a standards editor. And it’s how you work through them, what you ask, what you consider and how you explain your decision, that reveals your editorial judgment and helps you strengthen it.
In my first column, I wrote about why newsrooms need standards editors. But having someone to turn to is only the beginning. The harder question is what happens once everyone sits down to talk through a difficult call. Often, there’s no policy that quite fits. This is where some of the most valuable standards work happens.
Our role as standards editors is to be partners in the reporting process, building trust so colleagues feel comfortable bringing us difficult questions and working through the answers together.
One of the toughest things about making a big decision is the feeling that it creates a precedent, or a process by which all future decisions about the topic will be made.
In my experience, some of the toughest calls came when we had to talk through the details, hear each other out and consider what made that particular story different, without creating the expectation that every similar case would be handled the same way.
One of the greatest lessons I share with my Poynter students is something I learned when I was working on the standards desk at NBC News: Take things on a case-by-case basis.
This means that each decision, each story, each topic, is handled individually. Stories, like snowflakes, are all a little different once you zoom in. So we brought all the facts we had to the table, explored every angle we could think of and eventually made a decision. And that was it for that particular case.
The next day (or on a busy day, maybe in the next hour), a new challenge might present itself, and it would be addressed from scratch.
Taking decisions on a case-by-case basis doesn’t mean abandoning consistency. In fact, consistency is one of the most important responsibilities for a standards editor. Consistency doesn’t require identical outcomes. It asks us to apply the same journalistic principles and values, even when it leads us to different conclusions.
Making the call under pressure
On Jan. 24, 2026, Alex Pretti was shot and killed by immigration agents in Minneapolis. My former colleague Nina Sen was working on the standards desk at NBC News. Nina is NBC’s director of standards, race, class and gender. She quickly realized that reporting Pretti’s death would be complicated.
“Federal officials offered one account of what happened, but eyewitness videos challenged significant elements of that narrative,” Sen said. “I was working alone on a weekend. Of course, broadcasting footage of someone being killed raises serious questions. The images were disturbing, but I recognized immediately that they weren’t simply videos of a fatal shooting. They were evidence that allowed the public to examine what happened rather than rely solely on one narrative.”
The NBC News standards team oversees the company’s networks and platforms. The team includes some of the most collaborative, thoughtful, caring and laser-sharp journalists I’ve ever worked with. On that day, Nina had to make a tough call in a tight time window.
“We often focus on the risks of publishing disturbing material, but withholding it carries risks, too,” she said. “In this case, the public interest was clear. Not showing the footage would have been an editorial decision with consequences for trust and credibility.
“Sometimes waiting is the responsible choice. Other times, the evidence is there, the public needs to see it and the responsibility is to act quickly.”
That day, Nina chose to approve the video to be shown live on air. Pretti’s horrific death was a major story for weeks, and the footage helped shape the national discourse around ICE and its role in U.S. cities.
“Our responsibility isn’t to map the path of least resistance or criticism,” Nina said. “What matters is that we understand why we’re showing something, what it contributes to the reporting and whether we’re prepared to stand behind that choice. These are the kinds of decisions editors, whether they have standards in their job title or not, make every day in big and small newsrooms.”
Nina’s decision shows something important about standards work: Our responsibility isn’t to simply identify the risks in publishing, but also the risks of withholding information even when the material is difficult. Good standards work recognizes that tension and leads to decisions that can be explained and defended.
That’s one example of working in a gray area. Learning how to navigate that mostly undefined process makes you better at standards work. It’s a skill that can be developed with experience.
“I have strong instincts and I trust them,” Sen said. “I’m also a lifelong student. I don’t want to only know what we’ve done before, I want to know why. A decision that was right in one situation may not be right in another. I’m comfortable challenging conventional wisdom and reaching a different conclusion when the evidence supports it.”
She’s right that good decision-making can often start with a “gut check.”
When I teach ethical decision-making, I emphasize understanding yourself. A physical sensation can be a signal to pause: tension in your gut or anxiety about a photo, a source choice, a headline or even a broader assignment that could harm a source, your publication or your reputation.
A good standards editor then knows how to dig deeper to separate that initial feeling from the facts and context.
When I teach ethical leadership in Poynter’s leadership programs, I often start by presenting a slide that is entirely gray, and I let it sit there for a moment. The point is simple: newsroom leaders have to get comfortable in the gray zone, even when it feels isolating and overwhelming.
Earlier in my career, when I first joined that NBC standards team, I wanted a set of rules that gave me a clear answer every time. Slowly, experience on the job made me more open. I learned to listen closely to the reporter who knew the story more than I did, understand the editor’s concerns and look for a path to yes when the reporting was solid. That did not mean relaxing our standards. It meant asking whether there was another way to tell an important, verified story while addressing the risks that gave us pause.
My former colleague Nina has learned to embrace that process.
“I think a little doubt in a gray area is healthy. It keeps editors curious and open to the possibility there’s something more to learn, or even something missed,” she said.
“I try to make decisions that are informed, deliberate and defensible. Important journalism often requires taking risks, and I believe standards should help newsrooms take the right risks.”
Remember your shared values and principles
When there’s uncertainty, start with what you share as a news organization: a commitment to seek truth and report it, minimize harm, act independently and be accountable and transparent. Which of those values are at stake? What happens when they conflict?
Bring the conversation back to your newsroom’s mission. What have you promised your audience? Does this story help you deliver on that promise? And does the work your newsroom rewards reflect the values it says it holds?
How you have that conversation matters, too. Journalists may have spent months on a story before a standards editor gets involved. Asking them to reconsider something takes care and respect.
“You can be direct without being dismissive, and you can disagree without making someone feel that their work isn’t valued,” Sen said.
“I see my role as helping journalists do ambitious, consequential work. Sometimes I challenge a journalist’s approach. Other times, I’m the one encouraging them to go further.”
Ultimately, a good standards editor should make the story stronger and the audience smarter.
The best standards conversations don’t always end with a yes or no. They push the story forward and lead to an alternative nobody had considered. Identify a source differently. Add more context. Present an image or video another way. Use a public statement while making clear what has and hasn’t been independently verified. These are all ways to preserve the value of the reporting while addressing legitimate ethical concerns.
That’s why standards editors should be partners in the reporting process, not simply the people called in to approve or reject a story.
Look beyond the facts
A story can be accurate and still raise ethical questions. What context is missing? What might the audience take away from it? Could someone be harmed for the sake of being accurate, and is there another way to tell the story?
Nina offered this example: “A story can be factually accurate in every detail and still leave the audience with the wrong impression. You might accurately report a series of violent crimes, for example, but if the broader data shows crime is declining, the way you frame that coverage matters enormously.”
Another example is revealing a vulnerable source’s identity for the sake of accuracy and transparency while putting that person at greater risk of harm. Accuracy, fairness and transparency are crucial to our work, but they can sometimes conflict. Naming a vulnerable source may serve accuracy and transparency, but it may not be fair to expose that person to further harm.
Sometimes these are difficult calls, and talking them through with colleagues will always help us see what we might be missing. We need to give these decisions the time and attention they deserve, even if we’re under deadline.
At our ethical decision-making workshop, we give journalists 10 questions to help them work through this process. Developed by Poynter’s Roy Peter Clark, Bob Steele and other faculty members, the questions can help us think through difficult decisions and explain the choices we make.
- What do I know? What do I need to know?
- What is my journalistic purpose? Name the most important public service this work provides.
- What are my ethical concerns? Describe the conflict directly, including the loyalties or values in tension.
- Are there any policies or guidelines I should consider? Check your newsroom standards and discuss how they apply to the circumstances.
- How can I include other people with different perspectives? Seek input that can reveal a blind spot.
- Who are the stakeholders? Which ones have an important stake I should consider? Consider who could benefit, who could be harmed and whose perspective is missing.
- What if the roles were reversed? Consider how reversing the roles might change your perspective on the decision.
- What are the possible consequences of my actions? Consider foreseeable effects on sources, the audience, colleagues and public trust.
- What alternatives maximize my purpose? Ask what other ways of telling the story achieve the journalistic goal.
- How can I describe my decision to my colleagues or my audience? Be able to explain how you reached your decision and why you believe it was justified.
These questions will not always lead everyone to the same answer, and that’s OK. What matters is that we take the facts and information we have, challenge our assumptions, listen to different perspectives and consider everyone involved. After all, the gray zone is where many consequential decisions are made.
A good standards editor should never pretend to have all the answers. We should be partners who help our colleagues strengthen their reporting in service to the public.
This is Part 2 in a series on the role of a standards editor.
