Nieman Journalism Lab
New York Times developer Jacob Harris explains why “every time I see a word cloud presented as insight, I die a little inside.” The reason: Word clouds don’t live up to the best practices of data journalism. “At The New York Times, we strongly believe that visualization is reporting, with many of the same elements that would make a traditional story effective: a narrative that pares away extraneous information to find a story in the data; context to help the reader understand the basics of the subject; interviewing the data to find its flaws and be sure of our conclusions.” Simply counting the frequency of words and arranging them artistically doesn’t help the reader understand the information, Harris writes. A word cloud of the Iraq war logs, for instance, merely tells readers that the war involves a lot of of IEDs and explosions, “which is likely news to nobody.” || Related: Responding to Chase Davis and Matt Wynn’s post about treating news apps as products, Reginald Chua notes that one problem inhibiting news apps is that “we haven’t yet developed broadly-accepted conventions of how to explore data – so non-geeks (and even geeks) have to learn how to use each app individually.”
Uncategorized
New York Times developer: Word clouds are bad data journalism
More News
Opinion | Wall Street Journal marks one year of reporter’s detainment in Russian jail
Evan Gershkovich was arrested a year ago today in Russia while on a reporting assignment for the Journal
March 29, 2024
A Baltimore bridge collapsed in the middle of the night and two metro newsrooms leapt into action
Coverage from The Baltimore Sun and The Baltimore Banner had much in common but with some marked differences — especially in visuals.
March 29, 2024
Private equity reporting grants show good return
Projects in Hawaii, Milwaukee and south central Indiana knit news organizations into community life
March 29, 2024
Opinion | How misinformation will be gender-based in Ghana’s upcoming elections
Fact-checkers must be on the lookout for narratives that target and diminish women candidates
March 29, 2024
Opinion | The bombing of Erbil is a case study in misinformation
Real events spawn online fabrications, making data analysis an important tool for truth
March 29, 2024
Comments are closed.
Comments